August 20, 2025
With countless options available, most course creators find themselves weighing three main paths: established all-in-one platforms like Teachable and Thinkific, or building custom website solutions.
Selecting the right platform for your online course is one of the most crucial decisions you'll make as a course creator. This choice affects everything from your daily workflow and user experience to your long-term business growth and profitability. With dozens of options available, the three most common paths are established all-in-one platforms like Teachable and Thinkific, or building a custom website solution. Each approach offers distinct advantages and trade-offs that align differently with various business models, technical capabilities, and growth strategies. Understanding these differences upfront can save you significant time, money, and headaches down the road.
Teachable has established itself as one of the most popular course platforms, serving over 100,000 creators worldwide. Its strength lies in providing a comprehensive solution that handles course delivery, user management, payment processing, and basic marketing tools in one integrated package. The platform excels at simplicity—you can have a course online within hours without any technical knowledge. Teachable's course player is polished and mobile-responsive, offering features like progress tracking, completion certificates, and discussion forums. The platform handles all technical maintenance, security updates, and hosting, allowing creators to focus entirely on content creation and user success.
Teachable operates on a freemium model with paid plans ranging from $39 to $665 per month, plus transaction fees that decrease as you upgrade plans. The free plan includes basic features but adds Teachable branding and charges 10% transaction fees plus payment processing fees. Higher-tier plans reduce transaction fees and add advanced features like custom domains, affiliate programs, and advanced analytics. For many creators, the convenience justifies the costs, especially when factoring in the time and technical expertise required for alternatives. However, these fees can significantly impact profitability as your business scales.
Thinkific positions itself as a more customizable alternative to Teachable, offering greater control over branding and user experience while maintaining ease of use. The platform provides more design flexibility, better course structuring options, and stronger community features than many competitors. Thinkific's quiz and assignment tools are particularly robust, making it attractive for creators who need sophisticated assessment capabilities. The platform also offers better integration options with third-party tools and provides more detailed analytics for tracking user progress and business performance.
Thinkific offers a free plan that includes unlimited courses and users but limits some features and includes Thinkific branding. Paid plans range from $36 to $499 per month without transaction fees, making it potentially more cost-effective than Teachable for high-volume creators. The platform's pricing structure rewards growth without penalizing success through percentage-based fees. Thinkific Plus offers white-label solutions for larger organizations, providing complete platform customization for enterprises and established course creators who need maximum control.
Building a custom website for course delivery offers unparalleled control over every aspect of your business, from design and functionality to data ownership and revenue optimization. Popular approaches include WordPress with learning management system (LMS) plugins like LearnDash or LifterLMS, or custom-built solutions using platforms like Laravel or React. Custom solutions allow for unique branding, specialized functionality, and integration with any third-party tools or services. You own all customer data, have complete control over the user experience, and can optimize for search engines more effectively than on hosted platforms.
Custom website development requires significantly more technical expertise and ongoing maintenance than hosted platforms. Initial development costs can range from a few thousand dollars for basic WordPress LMS setups to tens of thousands for fully custom solutions. Ongoing costs include hosting, security monitoring, software updates, and technical support. You'll need either personal technical skills or reliable development partners to handle maintenance, troubleshooting, and feature updates. While total costs can be lower than platform fees for high-revenue courses, the technical overhead is substantial.
User experience varies significantly across platform types. Teachable and Thinkific offer polished, tested user experiences that work well across devices and browsers. Users familiar with these platforms may feel more comfortable with the familiar interface. However, custom solutions can create unique, branded experiences that align perfectly with your overall business identity. The trade-off is between proven usability and customized experience. Consider your audience's technical comfort level and expectations when evaluating platform options.
Custom websites generally offer superior SEO capabilities, allowing for complete control over site structure, content optimization, and technical SEO factors. You can optimize for any keywords, create content marketing strategies, and build domain authority over time. Hosted platforms like Teachable and Thinkific provide limited SEO control, though they do offer custom domains and basic optimization features. However, they also provide built-in marketing tools like affiliate programs, coupon systems, and email marketing integrations that might require additional setup on custom sites.
As your course business grows, platform choice becomes increasingly important. Hosted platforms scale automatically in terms of technical infrastructure but may become cost-prohibitive as revenue increases. Transaction fees can eat into profits significantly at higher volume levels. Custom solutions require more planning for scale but offer complete control over costs and functionality. Consider your growth projections and business model when making platform decisions, what works for a side business might not work for a full-time course creator.
Switching platforms later is possible but often challenging and expensive. Teachable and Thinkific provide export tools, but moving to custom solutions requires significant technical work. Moving from custom to hosted platforms can result in functionality loss. Plan for the long term and choose platforms that can grow with your business. If uncertain, starting with hosted platforms and migrating to custom solutions later is often easier than the reverse.
Choosing between Teachable, Thinkific, and custom website solutions requires careful consideration of your business goals, technical capabilities, and growth plans. Hosted platforms excel at providing complete solutions with minimal technical overhead, making them ideal for many course creators. Custom solutions offer maximum control and flexibility but require significant technical investment. The best choice is the one that aligns with your current needs while providing a clear path for future growth. Regardless of your platform choice, focus on creating valuable content and serving users effectively, the platform is just a tool to deliver your educational mission.
We are sending a weekly email newsletter answering questions from the space in a condensed format.
You can almost read it in an eye glance.
